|
Evaluating
Websites
|
|
After you have focused your search by
using the Internet Search Tips provided on this site, you
must now evaluate the reliability of the sites you have
located. Remember, anyone can claim to be an expert on your
research topic. This does not mean the information is always
accurate. You can follow some basic guidelines that will
help you identify the more reliable sites. For more
information, visit Wolfgram
Memorial Library's website.
|
|
1. Know the meaning of abbreviations
found in URLs
- Business or News Web Pages :
.com (commercial) indicates the site is associated with a
business. Online newspapers and magazines are included in
this category. These sites promote the sales of products
or services.
- Informational Web Pages: .edu
(education) or .gov (government) means the site is
developed through an educational institution (schools,
colleges) or sponsored by the government. These are used
for informational purposes only.
- Advocacy Web Pages: .org
(organization) tells you that the group sponsoring the
site is trying to influence public opinion or give
information about specific causes or issues.
- Personal Web Pages:
Individuals that create web pages may have any of the URL
endings listed above. Some of them may be associated with
a business or educational institution but are operating
their own site (i.e. a college professor may have .edu
appear in his URL). Look for a tilde ~ somewhere in the
URL. That will indicate it is a personal web
page.
|
|
2. Look at these five criteria to
evaluate how reliable a site might be. If you still have
questions after using these criteria, ask your teacher about
the site.
- Who is the author or producer?
Who is responsible for providing the information in the
site? If you cannot find a person or group's name, then
that site may not contain reliable
information.
- How accurate is the material in
the site? Look for obvious errors in content compared
to other reliable sources you have used. Are the facts
correct? Does the site have any/many grammatical or
typographical problems? If you answer "yes" to either of
those two questions, do not use the site for
research.
- Is the information presented
objectively? Does the author present information that
has no factual support? Does the author seem to favor one
side of an issue more than another? If so, this may not
be a reliable website.
- How current is the
information? Some research topics need updated
information. Look for copyright dates and/or revision
dates.
- How thorough is the coverage of
your topic? More helpful sites will include in-depth
coverage of your topic. If it does not have much, look
for a better site.
|
|
Teachers: Check out
Wolfgram
Memorial Library's "Evaluating Web
Pages" and Ithaca's
"ICYouSee T is for Thinking" for
collections of web pages that can be used for teaching
lessons about website evaluation.
|